Apollo, Bain LBOs Lose Investors' Money, Bonds Show

(Bloomberg) -- Less than a year after Apollo Management LP paid $6.6 billion for real estate broker Realogy Corp., bond prices show the deal may be worthless.

Debt used to finance the April purchase trades at 61 cents on the dollar, and derivatives tied to the securities indicate an 80 percent chance that Parsippany, New Jersey-based Realogy will default. Apollo, the private-equity firm run by Leon Black, put up about $2 billion of cash to buy the owner of Coldwell Banker and Century 21, borrowing the rest.

The bonds show Apollo's equity in Realogy ``has no value right now,'' said Sabur Moini, a money manager in Los Angeles at Payden & Ragel, which oversees $50 billion in fixed-income securities. ``If bonds are trading in the 50s or 60s, the market is saying that these guys are headed toward bankruptcy.''

Falling bond prices are jeopardizing private-equity returns after easy access to cheap debt fueled a record $1.4 trillion of leveraged buyouts in 2006 and 2007. New York-based Morgan Stanley estimates buyout funds raised in 2003 have returned an average of 42 percent, and now Apollo, Bain Capital LLC, Cerberus Capital Management LP and their competitors may face losses.

Twenty-seven percent of the approximately $74 billion in bonds used in LBOs the last two years classify as ``distressed'' because they yield at least 10 percentage points more than Treasuries, Bloomberg data show.

Distressed Defaults

About 19 percent trade at less than 80 cents on the dollar, below the 91-cent average for high-yield bonds, Bloomberg data show. Freescale Semiconductor Inc., an Austin, Texas-based maker of chips for mobile phones, and OSI Restaurant Partners Inc., the Tampa, Florida-based owner of Outback Steakhouse, are in both categories.

Debt is 20 times more likely to default within a year once it's crossed the distressed threshold, according to research by Martin Fridson, chief executive officer of high-yield research firm FridsonVision LLC in New York.

``There's going to be some blow-ups'' as the economy slows, said Eric Bushell, the chief investment officer at Toronto-based Signature Funds, which oversees $17 billion and invests in publicly traded buyout funds. LBO firms ``paid prices that maybe weren't necessary,'' he said.

LBO firms typically seek out investors such as pension funds or university endowments to fund 32 percent of the cost of any buyout on average, according to Standard & Poor's. They borrow the rest through high-yield, or junk, bonds and loans in the target company's name. Junk bonds are rated below Baa3 by Moody's Investors Service and lower than BBB- by S&P.

 

Read more at Bloomberg